Skip to main content
Pappy's Pizza NY Style logo top - HomepagePappy's Pizza NY Style logo scroll - Homepage
  • (770)-769-4304
  • teamnizzari@gmail.com
  • Menu
  • Drinks
  • Specials
  • Events
  • Order
    • order fromSlice
    • order fromDoordash
    • order fromUber Eats
  • Parties
  • Catering
  • Jobs
  • Facebook page
  • Instagram page
  • Google page
Pappy's Pizza NY Style logo top - HomepagePappy's Pizza NY Style logo scroll - Homepage
  • Order, opens in a new tab
  • Menu
  • Drinks
  • Specials
  • Events
  • Order
    • order fromSlice
    • order fromDoordash
    • order fromUber Eats
  • Parties
  • Catering
  • Jobs

Our Menu

  • Menu

Dine-in Prices Only

Appetizers

Fries

$3.90

Chips

$3.90

Fried Mozzarella Sticks

$8.31

Fried Mushrooms

$7.27

Fried Ravioli

$8.31

Meatballs

$5.19

Breadsticks w/ Cheese

$8.83

Loaded Fries

$13.48
Bacon, ground beef, onions, jalapenos, mozzarella cheese

Spinach & Artichoke Dip

$10.40

Bruschetta

$8.42

Salads

Dressings: Golden Italian · Thousand Island · Ranch · Bleu Cheese Chunky • Greek • Caesar • Oil & Vinaigrette • Honey Mustard • Balsamic

Ask about Chef Pappy Creations

House Salad

$4.16/Side
$6.24/Small
$8.32/Large
Lettuce, tomato, red onions & cucumbers.

Caesar Salad

$4.16/Side
$6.24/Small
$8.32/Large
Romaine, shredded parmesan, crouton, caesar dressing.

Greek Salad

$10.90/Small
$12.98/Large
Lettuce, green olives, kalamata olives, feta cheese, red onions & banana peppers.

Italian Salad

$10.90/Small
$12.98/Large
Lettuce, tomato, red onions, ham, salami, capicola, provolone cheese, marinated artichokes, roasted red peppers with oil & vinegar

Add Bacon

Side $0.78 | Small $1.04 | Large $2.08

Add Cheese

Side $0.78 | Small $1.04 | Large $2.08

Add Croutons

Side $0.52 | Small $0.78 | Large $1.54

Add Grilled Chicken

Small $3.11 | Large $5.20

Add Fried Chicken

Small $3.11 | Large $5.20

Add Ham

Small $1.04 | Large $2.08

Add Salami

Small $2.08 | Large $3.11

Chicken Wings & Baskets

Try any of our great flavors! Mild (but still spicy) · Mild (But Still Spicy) · Hot · BBQ · Lemon Pepper · Teriyaki · Sweet Thai Chili · Garlic Parmesan · Hot Honey · Xtra Hot · Jamaican Jerk · Kickin’ Bourbon · Honey Bourbon BBQ

Baskets served w/ fries | Extra Sauce 2oz 0.52 | 4oz 0.78

Every Wednesday: 1.00 Wings & 10.00 Pitchers

Original or Boneless Wings

$10.39/6
$15.38/10
$25.99/18
$33.27/24
$47.62/36
$67.38/50

Chicken Wings

$13.51/6
$18.71/10

4 Chicken Tenders

$13.51
W/ sauce +$14.55

Pappy's Pizza

Specialty toppings: Steak · Chicken · Anchovies · Eggplant
Cheese: Mozzarella · Cheddar · Ricotta · Feta · Parmesan · Provolone
Meats: Sausage · Pepperoni · Bacon · Ground Beef · Ham · Meatballs
Veggies: Garlic · Onions · Artichoke Hearts · Green Peppers · Mushrooms · Black Olives · Spinach · Tomato · Pineapple · Jalapeno Peppers · Green Olives · Banana Peppers · Roasted Red Peppers

Cheese Pizza

$2.34/Slice
$11.43/12" Round
$15.59/16" Round

1-Topping

$1.03/Slice
$2.34/12" Round
$3.12/16" Round

Chicken, Steak, or Extra Cheese

$3.12/12" Round
$5.20/16" Round

Gluten Free Crust

$11.43/10" Round
Toppings +1.82 each | Extra Red sauce 1.00 | Extra Alfredo Sauce 2.50

Cauliflower Crust

$11.43/10" Round
Toppings +1.82 each | Extra Red sauce 1.00 | Extra Alfredo Sauce 2.50

Extra Red Sauce

$1.00/12" Round
$2.00/16" Round

Extra Alfredo Sauce

$2.50/12" Round
$3.50/16" Round

Pizza Bowls

Choose 5 toppings. Specialty toppings excluded.
Chicken/Steak: SM 2.07 • LG 4.14

Pizza Bowls

$11.37/Small
$13.51/Large

Specialty Pizzas

An additional 2.00 charge for specialty split pizzas
Extra Sauce Available For An Additional Charge
Specialty toppings: Steak · Chicken · Anchovies · Eggplant
Cheese: Mozzarella · Cheddar · Ricotta · Feta · Parmesan · Provolone
Meats: Sausage · Pepperoni · Bacon · Ground Beef · Ham · Meatballs
Veggies: Garlic · Onions · Artichoke Hearts · Green Peppers · Mushrooms · Black Olives · Spinach · Tomato · Pineapple · Jalapeno Peppers · Green Olives · Banana Peppers · Roasted Red Peppers

Pappy’s Special

$16.63/12"
$22.87/16"
Up to 5 toppings, excludes specialty toppings

Supreme

$16.63/12"
$22.87/16"
Pepperoni, ground beef, sausage, mushrooms, black olives, green peppers

New York Deluxe

$16.63/12"
$22.87/16"
Extra cheese, black olives, pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, ham, bacon

Nanny’s Meat Lovers

$16.63/12"
$22.87/16"
Pepperoni, ham, ground beef, bacon, sausage

California White

$16.63/12"
$22.87/16"
Cheese, spinach, tomato, ricotta, garlic

Bacon Chicken Ranch

$16.63/12"
$22.87/16"
Ranch base, chicken, tomato, bacon, onions, ranch dressing, mozzarella, cheddar

Bacon Chicken Alfredo

$16.63/12"
$22.87/16"
Bacon, grilled chicken, creamy alfredo sauce, mozzarella cheese, parsley

Buffalo Chicken

$16.63/12"
$22.87/16"
Grilled chicken, extra cheese, hot sauce, ranch sauce

Bacon Meatball Alfredo

$16.63/12"
$22.87/16"
Bacon, Italian meatball, creamy alfredo sauce, mozzarella cheese, parsley

The Manhattan

$16.63/12"
$22.87/16"
Double pepperoni, double sausage, extra cheese

Stuffed Pizza

$24.95/16"
Up to 5 toppings, excludes specialty toppings

Philly Cheesesteak

$19.75/12"
$24.95/16"
Steak, onions, peppers, mushrooms, mozzarella cheese

Baby Sicilian

$12.47
Pizza toppings +$2.43 each • Specialty toppings +$2.60 each

X-Large Sicilian

$21.82
Pizza Toppings 3.50 Each | Specialty Toppings 3.75 Each

Flat Bread

$16.63/Sm
$22.87/Lg
Up To 5 Toppings

Stromboli & Calzones

Served with a side of tomato sauce $13.51
Each extra topping (from pizza toppings) +$1.03
Specialty toppings: Steak · Chicken · Anchovies · Eggplant
Cheese: Mozzarella · Cheddar · Ricotta · Feta · Parmesan · Provolone
Meats: Sausage · Pepperoni · Bacon · Ground Beef · Ham · Meatballs
Veggies: Garlic · Onions · Artichoke Hearts · Green Peppers · Mushrooms · Black Olives · Spinach · Tomato · Pineapple · Jalapeno Peppers · Green Olives · Banana Peppers · Roasted Red Peppers

Create Your Own Stromboli

$13.51
Any 4 toppings - Excludes specialty toppings

Philly / Chicken Stromboli

$16.63
Beef or chicken, mozzarella cheese, sauteed green peppers, onions, and mushrooms

Chicken Ranch Stromboli

$16.63
Chicken, bacon, tomato, onions, ranch, mozzarella & cheddar

Dave’s Stromboli

$13.51
Pepperoni, jalapeno, pineapple, mozzarella

Pappy’s Favorite

$15.51
Salami, ham, pepperoni, peppers, onions

Create Your Own Calzone

$13.51
Any 3 toppings • Excludes specialty toppings

Louie’s Spinach Calzone

$13.51
Mozzarella, spinach, tomato, garlic & ricotta cheese

Dave’s Calzone

$13.51
Pepperoni, jalapeno, pineapple, mozzarella & ricotta cheese

Veggie Calzone

$14.55
Green peppers, onions, black olives, mushrooms, tomatoes, mozzarella & ricotta cheese

Pasta Entrees

Served with side salad and homemade garlic rolls

Baked Lasagna

$16.63
Layers of pasta, ricotta cheese, meat & Italian spices topped with romano & mozzarella cheese

Baked Stuffed Shells

$13.51
Cheese filled shells baked in tomato sauce & topped with romano & melted mozzarella cheese

Eggplant Parmigiana

$15.59

Chicken Parmigiana

$16.63
Boneless chicken breast baked in tomato sauce topped with romano & melted cheese. Served with a side of spaghetti with tomato sauce

Fettuccine Alfredo

$13.51
Fettuccine pasta in creamy alfredo sauce

Chicken Fettuccine Alfredo

$17.67
Grilled chicken with fettuccine pasta in creamy alfredo sauce

Shrimp Fettuccine Alfredo

$18.38
Grilled shrimp with fettuccine pasta in creamy alfredo sauce

Fettuccine Carbonara

$15.59
Fettuccine pasta tossed in a cream white wine alfredo sauce with mushrooms, diced onions, bacon, fresh garlic

Spaghetti with Tomato Sauce

$11.95

Spaghetti with Meat Sauce

$15.59

Spaghetti with Meatballs

$15.59

Shrimp Scampi

$18.38
Lemon and white wine butter sauce, fresh garlic over spaghetti

Chicken Piccata

$17.67
3 pieces of sautéed chicken with homemade lemon wine butter sauce with capers over spaghetti

Penne Mamma Mia

$17.67
Penne pasta in alfredo sauce, diced chicken, diced tomatoes, diced artichokes, and is oven-baked.

Tuscan Chicken Gnocchi

$17.67
3 pieces of sauteed chicken, gnocchi, spinach, roasted red peppers, in a creamy homemade Tuscan sauce

Baked Ziti

$13.51
Made with penne pasta, tomato sauce, ricotta cheese, and mozzarella

Heroes

All heroes are served with fries or chips
Add sauteed peppers, onions, or mushrooms for $0.52 each
Add extra cheese $0.78 | Add bacon for $0.52 each

Italian

$13.51
Ham, salami, capicola, provolone, lettuce, tomato, onions, oil, vinegar

Meatball Parmigiana

$13.51
Meatballs, mozzarella, tomato sauce, baked on sub roll

Chicken Parmigiana

$13.51
Breaded chicken cutlet, mozzarella, tomato sauce, baked on sub roll

Philly/ Chicken Cheesesteak

$13.51
Philly beef or chicken, mozzarella, sauteed mushrooms, peppers, and onions baked on a sub roll

Just for Kids

10 years old & under only

Chicken Fingers w/ Fries

$7.27

Spaghetti w/ Meatball

$7.27

Slice of Pizza w/ Drink

$5.19

Fettuccine Alfredo

$8.26
Fettuccine pasta in creamy alfredo sauce

Desserts

New York Cheesecake

$7.54

Cannoli

$7.54

Cheesecake Slice

$8.84
Raspberry White Chocolate Cheesecake · Turtle Cheesecake · Key Lime Cheesecake

Cake Slices

$8.84
Red Velvet · Oreo Cake · Reese’s Peanut Butter Cake · Carrot Cake · Raspberry White Mousse Cake · Chocolate Mousse Cake · German Chocolate Cake
  • Order, opens in a new tab